The 18-year-old Hall has become a key player for the Red Bulls, scoring 12 goals and adding four assists in all competitions this season. He made his debut for the club in September 2023, becoming the second youngest player in league history behind Freddy Adu. Hall's new contract, which lasts until the 2029-30 MLS season, makes him the youngest American and the first Red Bull academy product to sign a U-22 initiative contract.

ESPN Soccer reports that Hall has been a revelation for the Red Bulls this season, scoring 16 goals and adding five assists across all competitions. He was also named to the 2026 MLS All-Star team, the second youngest player in team history to do so. Hall's on-field awareness has been key to his success, and he believes that being aware of his surroundings is crucial to maximizing his abilities.

The Red Bulls have expressed their trust in Hall, with head of sport Julian de Guzman stating that he will continue to play a significant role for the club. Hall's future is uncertain, with clubs in Europe reportedly interested in signing him, but for now, his focus remains on his hometown club.